1868 Miner & Barkers Art Gallery 845 Broadway New York NY “Annual sale of the Artists Fund Society” December 22. 1868 Miner & Barkers Art Gallery 845 Broadway New York NY “Exhibition of the painting Esmeralda the great masterpiece of J Van Serius of Antwerp” November 12 – December 22. 1868-1869 American Watercolor Society New York NY held at the National Academy of Design New York NY “Second Winter exhibition of the American Society of Painters in Water Colors” [unknown dates]. 1868 Brooklyn Art Association (1859-1912) Brooklyn NY “Fall [sixteenth] exhibition” November 16-21. 1868 Miner & Barkers Art Gallery 845 Broadway New York NY “Exhibition of a large and elegant collection of modern oil paintings” November 10. 1868 Miner & Barkers Art Gallery 845 Broadway New York NY “Exhibition of modern oil-paintings” November 6. 1868 Miner & Barkers Art Gallery 845 Broadway New York NY “Exhibition of the painting New republic by Ferdinand Pauwels (1830-1904) : also a collection of very fine modern oil paintings by Robie E Verboeckhover H Scbaefels David Col D De Noter L Van Knyck Charles M Webb W Verauhutur Mellens and others” April 20. 1868 Brooklyn Art Association (1859-1912) Brooklyn NY “Spring [fifthteenth] exhibition” March 17-21. 1868 Buffalo Fine Arts Academy Buffalo NY held at Young Mens Association Buildings Buffalo NY “Sixth annual exhibition” February 19 – [unknown date]. 1868 National Academy of Design New York NY “Forty-third annual exhibition” [unknown date]. 1867-1868 American Watercolor Society New York NY held at the National Academy of Design New York NY “First Winter exhibition of the American Society of Painters in Water Colors” December 20 1867 – February 1868.